Apple Cider Margaritas

*This post is intended only for individuals who are of 21 years of age or older.

I don’t know about all of you, but fall is quite possibly my favorite season. Despite all of the complaining that I do about Illinois weather, I’m grateful to be in a state where we get to experience the four seasons at one point or another. The smell of a bonfire on a crisp night, cuddled up in an oversized hoodie with a hot cup of apple cider in my hands = night made.

So yes, this Apple Cider Margarita is a bit different than my norm for a fall drink being that it is cold. My husband and kids will drink apple cider cool, but I only like mine hot -preferably with a little bit of whipped cream and cinnamon sprinkled on top. A couple weeks ago I actually made a trip to the grocery store for the sole purpose of getting whipped cream to top off my cup of hot cider -Ben looked at me like I was nuts. Hey, I want what I want?!

Anyhow, this recipe came about on a night that we were hosting a football game after party; a Football Fiesta if you will. Tacos, chips and salsa, obviously a margarita would fit in as the signature drink, except margaritas make me think of summertime, not fall time. What better way to throw a fall twist on a summer drink than to add some apple cider? Boom. The Apple Cider Margarita was born.

*This post contains affiliate links which means that I can earn a commission off of purchases made via click throughs on these links. Thank you for your support!

Apple Cider Margarita

Since I was making this for a party, my first attempt at this drink was done in bulk. One of my friends at the party wanted the recipe to make for her husband’s birthday party in the following weeks. Of course, I didn’t bother with measurements the first time around and was just throwing things in until I thought it tasted good. Today, I made a single serving (12 oz glass) for the sole purpose of recording the ingredients. If you’ve got a party -I’ll let you do the math ;-). I’m terrible at calculating things like this because I never want to run out and therefore I always end up with way too much left over!

Apple Cider Margarita

Ingredient List


  1. Cut orange by slicing the ends off first and then slicing so that you have circles like in the above picture. Cut 1/2 of apple so that you can get a circular slice similar in size to your orange slice. Set aside.
  2. Dice other 1/2 of apple into small pieces and mix in a small bowl of cinnamon and sugar. I maybe used 8 small pieces. You just need enough cinnamon and sugar to coat the apples. Set aside.
  3. Fill glass with ice.
  4. Pour Margarita, Apple Cider, and diced apples over the top of ice and then pour into another glass, back and forth a few times.* Let drink mixture sit in the glass that you aren’t going to drink out of for a moment.
  5. Take an orange slice and move it around the rim of the glass that are you are going to drink out of. (You want to apply a thin layer of juice from the orange to the rim so that you can get the cinnamon and sugar to stick to it).
  6. If your same small bowl of cinnamon sugar from step 2 is dry, go ahead and press the rim of the glass that is now coated in orange juice into the cinnamon sugar. You may have to move the glass around a bit to cover the rim with cinnamon sugar. If your cinnamon sugar mixture is wet from the diced apples, add a little bit more cinnamon and sugar to the bowl before pressing the lid in. If it is too wet, it won’t adhere to the rim well.
  7. Pour your drink mixture into your glass with the cinnamon sugar rim.
  8. Top it off with a splash of the Ginger Ale.
  9. Place one orange slice and one apple slice on the rim.
  10. Give yourself a pat on the back and sip when ready.
Apple Cider Margarita
Grab the cute glass here!

When I made this as a large batch I also added in some Mandarin Orange Sparkling Water, extra sugar, and cut up a couple apples and oranges that I let sit in the large drink dispenser. If you are using a sweet apple cider, you can likely skip the extra sugar…if it is more tart then you might want to add it.

Apple Cider Margarita
Apple Cider Margarita

Next up? Probably something warm :-).


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *